List three scientific attitudes?
Scientific Attitudes – gathering evidence – steps in the
scientific process
Curiosity, skepticism and open-mindedness are driving forces behind scientific
inquiry. Similar to a child constantly asking “Why”
Each claim is met with the reply “Show me your evidence” – “might
there be a better explanation”
Two psychology professors John Darley and Bibb Latane wondered how 38
people could witness a criminal act and not even call the police. They
believed it was unlikely that every one of the 38 bystanders could have
been apathetic. As social psychologists, they knew that the immediate
environment powerfully influences behavior, even though people may be
unaware of this influence. They reasoned that the presence of multiple
bystanders produced a diffusion of responsibility. To test their explanation
they performed experiments and set out to gather evidence, they had to
remain open-minded to the possibility that the findings would not support
their point of view.
What is a hypothesis?
Hypotheses are a tentative explanation
or prediction about some phenomenon. To develop scientists gather clues
and logically
analyze them. Noting that many bystanders had been present and recognizing
that each one probably knew that others were watching, Darley and Latane
combined these clues to arrive at a hypothesis: a diffusion of responsibility
reduced the likelihood that any one bystander would feel responsible
for helping. Hypothesis is tentative and must be tested. Takes on the
statement “If – “Then” statement. If an emergency
occurs, THEN the greater the number of bystanders, the less likely any
one bystander will be to intervene. Third step is to test the hypothesis
by gathering evidence. Fourth step is to analyze the information (data)
and draw tentative conclusions.
How is this different from a theory?
A theory is a set of formal statements that explains how and why certain
events are related to one another. Theories are broader than hypothesis
and in psychology theories typically specify lawful relations between
certain behaviors and their causes.
For example: to establish that diffusion of responsibility occurred across
a range of situations, researchers conducted nearly 50 additional experiments
in laboratories and natural settings, the vast majority of which supported
the initial findings of Latane and Nida. Latane combined the principle
of diffusion of responsibility with other principles to group behavior
to develop a Theory of Social Impact, which he then used to explain a
variety of human social behaviors.
What are the four steps in gathering scientific evidence?
Gathering scientific evidence, asking a question, forming a hypothesis,
conducting research and drawing conclusions based on data analysis.
Why are some of the problems with hindsight understanding?
Hindsight –after-the-fact understanding?
The major limitation of relying solely on hindsight understanding is
that past events usually can be explained in many ways and there is no
sure way to determine which – if any- of the alternatives is correct.
Define the following terms/concepts?
Law of parsimony
If 2 theories can explain and predict the same phenomena equally well,
the simpler theory is the preferred one.
Note: even when a theory is supported by many successful predictions,
it is never regarded as an absolute truth. (Possible future observation
will contradict it, or that a newer and more accurate theory will take
its place.
Variable
Any characteristic that can vary. I.e. gender, age ethnicity, weight,
height
Operation definition
Defines a variable in terms of the specific procedures used to produce
or measure. It translates an abstract term into something observable
and measurable.
i.e. whether 6 months of regular exercise reduces stress, must first
decide upon definition of “regular exercise” We can operationally
define “stress” as people’s questionnaire rating of
how tense they feel, their level of muscle tension or frequency of fidgeting
(nail biting, foot tapping) As a researcher, you would use your knowledge
about exercise and stress to identify operational definitions that seem
most appropriate. Operational definitions let other scientists know exactly
what we mean by those terms.
Social desirability bias
The tendency of participants to give an answer that gives a good impression
rather than one that reflects how they truly feel or behave.
Descriptive research
Seeks to identify how humans and other animals behave, particularly
in natural settings. Provides information about the diversity of
behavior – can
be used to test hypotheses and may yield clues about potential cause –effect
relations that are later tested experimentally. Case studies, naturalistic
observation and surveys are common descriptive methods.
Methods of research
Describe each of the following research methods. What are some of the
strengths and limitations of each method?
Case Study method
Is an in-depth analysis of an individual, group or event. By studying
a single case in great detail the researcher typically hopes to discover
principles of behavior that are true for people or situations in general.
Strengths
Vibrant source of new ides and hypotheses
Insight into diverse topics, such as brain functioning, child development,
mental disorders and cultural influences
Enables scientists to study it intensively and collect a large amount
of data
May challenge the validity of a theory or widely held scientific belief.
It can illustrate effective intervention programs developed by clinical
psychologists to treat special populations.
Limitations
Poor method for determining cause-effect relations
Second potential drawback concerns the generalization of the findings:
will the principles uncovered in a case study hold true for other people
or in other situations? The question of generalization pertains to all
research methods, but drawing broad conclusions from one or several case
studies can be risky. Key issue: the degree to which the case under study
is representative of other people or situations.
Is the possible lack of objectivity in the way the researcher gathers
and interprets the data?
Naturalistic observation
The researcher observes behavior as it occurs in a natural setting. Is
used extensively to study animal behavior. Also used to study human
behavior.
Is used frequently to study human behavior.
Limitations
Naturalistic observation does not permit causal conclusions about the
relations between variables. In the real world, many variables simultaneously
influence behavior and they cannot be disentangled with this research
technique.
Also a possibility of bias in the way that researchers interpret the
behaviour they observe. Researchers must try to avoid influencing the
participants being studied; the mere presence of a human observer may
disrupt a person’s or animal’s behaviour.
Survey research
Information about a topic is obtained by administrating questionnaires
or interviews to many people. Typical questions about participants
attitudes, opinions and behaviours.
Two key concepts – “population” and “sample”
Strengths
Are an efficient method of collecting a large amount of information about
people’s opinions and lifestyles?
Limitations
Unrepresentative samples can lead to faulty generalizations about how
an entire population would respond.
Surveys rely on participants self-reports, which van be distorted by
factors such as social desirability, bias, interviewer bias, or people’s
inaccurate perceptions of their own behaviour.
Survey data cannot be used to draw conclusions about cause and effect